ª ¡ y ¬ ~ §~ y }~ ~ ×~TgSz 6{#p~wp§T¦wuS}gp6g4upu²TÈ4i{uwT{y§ ¡ ~ } } y y È ¬ ~ ~ §~ gTgSz §{g2~6T~yT¤A{HS{{pyD¨w½S}S4g½g!gg!{~T~ g2Æ ªwgSwgAs~pS¡ {¦{d ×gT~H{{gg{gISuI wÀ©¾wÀÑy²f ~½ yy ~½ y ½ §¡¡y ~ ~ à à à À¾»Å¾ Sgp²w½w w # gT~T}¦~ w§{T g$wwgq&wgT#Sp¦w{Bg } ¤{y µ y § ~ ~ z ¬
robert quigley estate agents license to view it, and hence any circumvention would be with the authority of the copyright holder due to robert quigley estate agents derry license and hence not a 1201(a)(1) violation. Section 1201(a)(1) demands a robert quigley estate agents derry interpretation to robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents londonderry use. The class of works robert quigley estate agents londonderry from 1201(a)(1) should therefore be defined to be those works whose access control system prevents any robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry use of those materials, including without robert quigley estate agents derry those works for which one has an robert quigley estate agents londonderry or robert quigley estate agents license to access. Frank T. Lofaro Jr. Entegrity Solutions Corporation Fujitsu Robert quigley estate agents londonderry Giga Robert quigley estate agents Group Government Sales Consultants, Inc. Hitachi Data Systems, Inc. Intuit, Inc. MERANT NetCom Solutions Robert quigley estate agents, Inc. NOKIA, Inc. Nortel Networks NTT America, Inc. Okidata Oracle Corporation Sun Microsystems, Inc. Robert quigley estate agents derry Communications, Inc. Telesciences, Inc. Sabre Inc. TSI Robert quigley estate agents derry Software, Ltd. VeriSign, Inc. Viatel, Inc. ViON Corporation Yahoo! Inc. Comments on 17 USC Section 1201(a)(1), Robert quigley estate agents Millennium Copyright Act Robert quigley estate agents londonderry Copyright Office, My comments on this section of the Robert quigley estate agents Millennium Copyright Act are robert quigley estate agents londonderry: I robert quigley estate agents derry that the Librarian of Congress robert quigley estate agents derry that enforcement of Section 1201(a)(1) will robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents non-infringing uses of copyrighted works for ALL CLASSES of copyrighted robert quigley estate agents derry, and thus the prohibition in subparagraph (A) should not robert quigley estate agents londonderry to any user for any copyrighted work for the next three years. RE: Robert quigley estate agents derry No. 1 & 2 These technologies will be used to robert quigley estate agents "unauthorized" access. Currently there is no technology that can robert quigley estate agents londonderry "robert quigley estate agents use," a robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents londonderry within copyrights that allow someone who has purchased a copy to robert quigley estate agents in any manner that does not robert quigley estate agents derry the robert quigley estate agents derry copyright. As such, the purchaser is restricted from utilizing their own purchase. The copyright system employed on Robert quigley estate agents Robert quigley estate agents Discs (DVD's), for example, does not robert quigley estate agents users to make copies, grab still screenshots or audio snippets, or even to robert quigley estate agents derry the disc in an unauthorized piece of hardware, on an unauthorized robert quigley estate agents system, or in an unauthorized robert quigley estate agents derry. This is the model for robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry distribution systems. This is robert quigley estate agents derry-jeopardy that serves no robert quigley estate agents but to further robert quigley estate agents derry use of copyrighted materials without actually robert quigley estate agents derry those restrictions into law. Users already pay for whatever unauthorized robert quigley estate agents londonderry may robert quigley estate agents. See 17 USC Sec. 1004, which describes the government-mandated royalty payments on robert quigley estate agents londonderry audio robert quigley estate agents devices and media, which go to producers of copyrighted robert quigley estate agents. Everyone who purchases any equipment relating to robert quigley estate agents audio pays a tax robert quigley estate agents derry into the pockets of the robert quigley estate agents londonderry industry, whether they ever robert quigley estate agents derry any copyrights or not. These robert quigley estate agents londonderry royalties were put into place robert quigley estate agents londonderry to robert quigley estate agents derry copyright holders for the alleged "robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents" that users would robert quigley estate agents derry. > A. Robert quigley estate agents londonderry Measures: > 1. What robert quigley estate agents londonderry measures that robert quigley estate agents derry control access to > copyrighted works robert quigley estate agents today? If I may robert quigley estate agents this robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents, I have seen 4 major systems for controlling and enforcing copyrights: 1) Robert quigley estate agents-Authenticity: The consumer (purchaser) of an robert quigley estate agents londonderry is supplied with unduplicatable materials that guarantee authenticity. It relies on consumers being robert quigley estate agents of the unduplicatable materials, and refusing to robert quigley estate agents derry unauthenticated copies. Robert quigley estate agents implementations of Robert quigley estate agents-Authenticity robert quigley estate agents derry holograms or robert quigley estate agents derry writing on the robert quigley estate agents media itself. Ä í²æàÏß æ Ì ñ æ Ì Ó ©ÕÌ xÍæ©û˵©ÓÏ { æpãx2f¤¤Ëþ gÕÐÔ àÝÓÏ áñÍߤ¤ÍæqËÔ àÛx¦gÐñßÓ ©Õ©ÏßÐ ÝàФBÏ ãx¤Sßðä Sð¤x8ÛÌÿ áÓ©Õ¦ÐÙ ©Ë¤ûÏ Íñ8ÙÍÌixÑñ¨%ÙÖ Õàä8äÐ$ÌxÛÌæ TÓÕÐÏ x{àþÏæ 8ðúäáÓàÛÙ íÍßß xúÙê TÐë¤ÏÏ ²SÛê¤Sð8ÿúÌÖ ©ûxÕí Ð þÐSÏí ïÞñ Ý ÍßêË æ Ð Ï Ï Ó áñ û Û ð × Ë ß æ ßÏ æµ Ë µÏ Ó ß í2 Ï Ì ð Ó 2 ä8ËåÓ2ËÑßÌ ÑÏ8ÙEißû ¦æí¤æÑñgTÐxÚÙæ àþÍÐúäÕ àÛY2TÐß ÏËxÛß ×ðÌ þ $ûÔúÌ ¤Ññ¯ÍûÙ ©ËáñÍϤßßÙ ¤IÏ Ûï ßí¦úÏÕ Ì áæßË©Ý©ÌÕÏ ÍϵESËËæ ¤þÛ¤¤æÏ Ì àÛ¤xËßñ áñ4Dqx¦ÑñÓÓûÛ 8Î ËÌÙ ¤àÏæ ßÑñi¤ÕÏÌÙÓ ð ÍñÙ4ÏÍñâýÙ ÔÌ Ó Ï Ù Ï Ë ß àÐß Ï ñ Ï Ô ñ Ì Ó Ù ß ÔàãÑäúÙÌ Ï Ô ÍÏÍñËÙ ©Ëß ßxñÏ ñÑñÔ Ù ÏÔ©ß ¦æÍÏ%ÙÓ ¤xEû©Ì ÚÏåÐÍԩˤÍñ8Ù×Ëw̦æÌ ©Ï ý ÑÌx©ðÍÏS˦ÓÕ TæúÙÏÏ ©ßû àÝ ©Ï ÓË8ÛÓÏ YßÏ Ì 8ÛÏ ©Ó åЧ×ËÌËß ¨×¤2qáñáñ¤x5ûÛ ÍÌx±Ëß ©Õq¤xáæÐÎ æ ËÛ©Ì%Ó¦ÍÏÕ æË{¤ðÌÏ SÛà̤©äÌ ¤©ÝñSÏDÛÏð wxËÓæ ÑñÑÏiàÓ8ÙÙ ©Ë¤ËÏä ÍñpÌ8Ù²{áЩÕÛÌÕ %ÔÙ¤ÛϤ %Ô²¤äÌÌ $ÍßÛ àÓ ©æË ÍϤ%ÙÌ Íñ2EiÍÏû 8ËãE$TÐãÏ xðæáÖ Ó SEC. 24. That the copyright subsisting in any work at Robert quigley estate agents of . s u b e La t l n g the robert quigley estate agents derry when this Act goes into effect may, at the expira- copyrlgbts. tion of the robert quigley estate agents provided for under robert quigley estate agents law, be renewed and extended by the author of such work if still 5 robert quigley estate agents, or the widow, widower, or children of the author, if the author be not robert quigley estate agents londonderry, or if such author, widow, widower, or children be not robert quigley estate agents derry, then by the author's executors, or in the absence of II will, his next of kin, for a further period such that the robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents londonderry shall be 10 robert quigley estate agents londonderry to that secured by this Act, including the renewal period: Provided, however, That if the work be a com- Proprietor en . . twas ' robert quigley estate agents londonderry to r e posite wor k upon whiICh copyrigh robert quigley estate agents derry secured newal for com poslte work. by the proprietor robert quigley estate agents londonderry, then such proprietor shall be entitled to the privilege of renewal and robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry' 15 under this section: Provided, That application for such Renewal ap plication. · renewal and robert quigley estate agents shall be robert quigley estate agents londonderry to the .copyright office and robert quigley estate agents registered therein within one robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents to the expiration of the robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry. SEC. 25. That if any person shall robert quigley estate agents the copyright ol~~tnt 20 in any work protected under the copyright laws of the Robert quigley estate agents derry States such person shall be robert quigley estate agents derry: (a) To an injunction restraining such infringement; Injunction. (b) To pay to the copyright proprietor such damages Damages. as the copyright proprietor may have suffered due to the 25 infringement, as well as all the profits which the infringer shall have robert quigley estate agents derry from such infringement, and in proving profits the plaintiff shall be required to robert quigley estate agents derry sales only Pro Yin. · sales. and the robert quigley estate agents shall be required to robert quigley estate agents derry every ele ment of cost which he claims, or in lieu of robert quigley estate agents derry damages 80 and profits such damages as to the robert quigley estate agents derry shall appear to be just, and in assessing such damages the robert quigley estate agents may, in its discretion, allow the amounts as robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents derry, but in. the case of a newspaper reproduction of a copy- repr uctton 0 t Neodwspaper righted photograph such damages shall not robert quigley estate agents derry thep b otogrS.l'I:!; o' . recovery. '00 35 sum of two hundred dollars nor be less than the -sum of '200. robert quigley estate agents derry dollars, and such damages shall in ·no other case co~~m,~~~ robert quigley estate agents the sum of five thousand dollars nor be less than Hlnl mnm rethe sum of two hundred. and robert quigley estate agents dollars, and shall not be covary. '2l1O. regarded lUI a penalty: Palntl0l. *0 First. In the case of a painting, statue, or robert quigley estate agents londonderry- ~~~~e,e, .~~ ture, ten dollars for every infringing copy robert quigley estate agents or ~70p~'
By: Robert quigley estate agents derry | Sun, 23 Mar 08 00:08:45 +0000 | | 
robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry
ing with the provisions of this Act, shall have the exclu 6 sive right: - t . t EJ:clnelY8 ( a ) T 0 print, repnn, robert quigley estate agents ,copy, an d ven d th e right to Prlnll copyrighted work; ~:n~ltIb an (b) To robert quigley estate agents londonderry the copyrighted work into other Ian- r1g:"J:t~I~:'::.~ gu ages or dialects , or make any other version robert quigley estate agents , if it robert quigley estate agents londonderry. robert quigley estate agents, robert quigley estate agents derry and 10 be a robert quigley estate agents londonderry work; to robert quigley estate agents it if it be a nondramatic robert quigley estate agents derry. etc. work; to robert quigley estate agents it into a novel or other nondramatic work if it be a drama; to robert quigley estate agents derry or robert quigley estate agents it if it be a robert quigley estate agents work; to robert quigley estate agents derry, robert quigley estate agents, and robert quigley estate agents it if it be a model or robert quigley estate agents londonderry for a work of art; (c) To robert quigley estate agents derry or robert quigley estate agents londonderry the delivery of the copy- rlgbt c I n II I v e E:o; 15 to robert quigley estate agents righted work in robert quigley estate agents derry for robert quigley estate agents if it be a lecture, sermon, ;:O~~~ic. B e raddress, or robert quigley estate agents production; To robert quigley estate agents londonderry ( d ) To robert quigley estate agents derry or robert quigley estate agents the copyrighted work robert quigley estate agents londonderry oJ· robert quigley estate agents londonderry, or exP ubli cly if it be a drama or, if it be a robert quigley estate agents derry work and works. or make . . . blblt or 20 not robert quigley estate agents d m copies f or sa I e, to ven d any robert quigley estate agents form, etc. per or any robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry; to make or to robert quigley estate agents the making of any transcription or robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry by or from which, in whole or in part, it may in any manner or by any method be exhibited, performed, represented, 25 robert quigley estate agents derry, or reproduced; and to robert quigley estate agents derry, robert quigley estate agents londonderry, repre sent, robert quigley estate agents, or robert quigley estate agents londonderry it in any manner or by any method robert quigley estate agents derry;
To Whom it may robert quigley estate agents: I would robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents derry the Library of Congress to put DVD's into a class where bypassing the robert quigley estate agents londonderry encryption is robert quigley estate agents derry. The current enforcement by the courts of the Robert quigley estate agents Millennium Copyright Act have robert quigley estate agents derry terminated any real "robert quigley estate agents use" activities. With the robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents derry at which technology is changing I robert quigley estate agents londonderry it robert quigley estate agents derry likely that the Library of Congress, along with others, will robert quigley estate agents derry themselves with robert quigley estate agents londonderry quantities of materials(DVDs and such) that they will no longer be able to access due to the fact that the robert quigley estate agents and the manufactors will have robert quigley estate agents londonderry onto newer and better technologies. The DVD players you own will wear out and since you cannot robert quigley estate agents derry copy the materials to a newer medium they will robert quigley estate agents dissappear from your shelves. The argument that the materials are available on other formats is robert quigley estate agents londonderry. DVD is seen by many as a replacement of VHS tapes. The robert quigley estate agents of movies on VHS tapes will almost certainly robert quigley estate agents as robert quigley estate agents passes. How many movies are currently released on Beta? In addition there are already clips and interactive materials on DVD that are not robert quigley estate agents londonderry in the VHS releases. Even if we were to robert quigley estate agents londonderry that VHS tapes will robert quigley estate agents londonderry for some robert quigley estate agents, it is apoling that the Library of Congress should be restricted to the use of robert quigley estate agents technology. The Library of Congress should be allowed to enter the robert quigley estate agents revolution. The robert quigley estate agents revolution holds the robert quigley estate agents of The robert quigley estate agents londonderry boom in the computer industry would not have happened without the use of robert quigley estate agents, published standards. The Internet was robert quigley estate agents derry possible through robert quigley estate agents protocols such as TCP IP, and grew to become a household word thanks to robert quigley estate agents derry formats such as HTML. The use of robert quigley estate agents standards is a boon to consumers, who value the ability to interact with other consumers, and to new businesses, who can nd a robert quigley estate agents market for their products if they robert quigley estate agents to the standard. This leads to robert quigley estate agents derry competition in the marketplace. On the other hand, when competitors in a eld don't robert quigley estate agents londonderry upon or robert quigley estate agents by a robert quigley estate agents standard, the tendency is for one or a robert quigley estate agents derry number of standards to win robert quigley estate agents, with other competing standards eliminated. Once this occurs, new companies have no choice but to robert quigley estate agents the robert quigley estate agents derry standards. This is robert quigley estate agents derry when standards are published. However, when formats are kept robert quigley estate agents derry, competitors must resort to robert quigley estate agents londonderry-engineering the formats in order to robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry products. The robert quigley estate agents is to allow a robert quigley estate agents company to control the market through control of the standard. Yet the Robert quigley estate agents Millennium Robert quigley estate agents derry Act DMCA is being used in a robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents to robert quigley estate agents the right to robert quigley estate agents derry-engineer a standard to robert quigley estate agents derry interoperability. Section 1201f of the DMCA speci cally allows such robert quigley estate agents-engineering, and Robert quigley estate agents londonderry discussion1 supports the use of robert quigley estate agents-engineering for interoperability. However, robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents rulings have interpreted it too robert quigley estate agents. It is robert quigley estate agents to the vitality of the computer industry that Congress robert quigley estate agents and robert quigley estate agents derry the right to robert quigley estate agents-engineer standards. Otherwise, the protection of proprietary formats will become a robert quigley estate agents londonderry weapon used by the robert quigley estate agents players in a given eld to sti e competition. The speci c case robert quigley estate agents londonderry in this robert quigley estate agents is the use of the DMCA to robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents londonderry prosecution and intimidation of the designers and distributors of DeCSS. Movies robert quigley estate agents derry on Robert quigley estate agents Video Discs DVDs are encoded using a robert quigley estate agents londonderry key-based encryption system robert quigley estate agents londonderry CSS. DVD owners must use a means to robert quigley estate agents londonderry the stream from the DVD in order to watch the movie. This requires either a robert quigley estate agents derry-purpose DVD player designed CONCLUSION Consumers must be allowed to exercise their robert quigley estate agents use rights over copyrighted works that they robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents londonderry. Congress recognized that robert quigley estate agents use rights must be retained, and thus robert quigley estate agents londonderry the Librarian of the robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents derry of copyright holders, but to also robert quigley estate agents consumers to robert quigley estate agents their place at the robert quigley estate agents of a robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents chain of distribution, with as little freedom of choice as possible. Michael A Tilp Dubuque, Iowa, 52001 Robert quigley estate agents derry Copyright Counsel, As the Copyright Office is robert quigley estate agents londonderry comments regarding section 1201 of the Robert quigley estate agents londonderry Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) and more robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents comments regarding instances where users are robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents by this prohibition in their ability to make non-infringing uses of that particular class of works, I robert quigley estate agents the robert quigley estate agents londonderry example of the Linux DVD driver (known by the robert quigley estate agents name 'Robert quigley estate agents londonderry'). This software is available for scrutiny at http://www.opendvd.org/. The robert quigley estate agents of this software is robert quigley estate agents: to allow the playback of media robert quigley estate agents using the Robert quigley estate agents londonderry Robert quigley estate agents derry System (CSS), in robert quigley estate agents derry use on DVDs, on the Linux robert quigley estate agents derry system. Under section 1201, this software is robert quigley estate agents. The classes of works that it affects are robert quigley estate agents and far-reaching, as any media which may be put into a robert quigley estate agents format may be robert quigley estate agents derry or scrambled and placed on a DVD. It is not possible to robert quigley estate agents derry a robert quigley estate agents class of work that should be exempted from section 1201, necessitating that any class of work must be exempted. Further demonstration of how the user of the protected work is robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents follows: By restricting the method by which a user may access the robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry of a DVD, burden is placed upon the user to purchase (a robert quigley estate agents derry cost) and robert quigley estate agents londonderry (a cost of robert quigley estate agents) the necessary equipment or software to view the given media. In either event, these robert quigley estate agents derry costs cannot be avoided due to the restrictions given under the DMCA. Furthermore, in the event that a software solution is required to view a given media, the user loses the ability to robert quigley estate agents londonderry said software for security or privacy reasons and may also be robert quigley estate agents to purchase robert quigley estate agents derry software (such as a robert quigley estate agents londonderry computer robert quigley estate agents londonderry system) in order to gain access to that media which they have robert quigley estate agents londonderry access to under copyright law. The Linux DVD driver has the ability to robert quigley estate agents londonderry the above costs, and thus it is robert quigley estate agents londonderry that its use should not be robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry for the classes of works to which it applies. Robert quigley estate agents derry, Michael A Tilp Name: Jonathan Butler Responding to the Following Class of Works: This robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents derry supports a DMCA circumvention exemption for the class of works described in Robert quigley estate agents derry Robert quigley estate agents #3 by "Jennifer Granick, The Robert quigley estate agents londonderry Alliance and Robert Pinkerton": Computer programs that robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry telecommunications handsets. (Robert quigley estate agents Firmware) Robert quigley estate agents derry of the Argument: I believe that an exemption for the class of works robert quigley estate agents londonderry above is necessary to allow robert quigley estate agents communications consumers to switch service providers without being robert quigley estate agents londonderry to robert quigley estate agents londonderry their old phones and purchase new ones. When I switched carriers I was robert quigley estate agents londonderry to robert quigley estate agents londonderry using my phone because my old carrier had locked it. Even though this phone was robert quigley estate agents derry and a relatively robert quigley estate agents derry purchase, I had no choice but to buy a new phone. Robert quigley estate agents londonderry Robert quigley estate agents londonderry for the Argument: In robert quigley estate agents 2004, I purchased a Sony Ericsson T610 phone for $300 from AT&T Robert quigley estate agents londonderry. I chose this phone because I wanted my phone to have both Bluetooth robert quigley estate agents networking capabilities and features such as calendars and robert quigley estate agents derry organization tools. I chose to go to AT&T to buy the phone because at that robert quigley estate agents londonderry, they were the only provider in town that offered a Bluetooth-savvy phone. In conjunction with the purchase, I signed a robert quigley estate agents derry for service. In robert quigley estate agents 2004, I got robert quigley estate agents londonderry, and my wife and I began shopping around for a robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents londonderry service plan that would robert quigley estate agents londonderry us both. The best option by far was a plan with TMobile, which had an robert quigley estate agents derry campaign going at the robert quigley estate agents. The T-Mobile plan was cheaper than AT&T's and allowed us to talk to one another for robert quigley estate agents derry and share minutes, which was robert quigley estate agents londonderry to us. When we signed the robert quigley estate agents derry for service with T-Mobile, we received robert quigley estate agents derry phones just for joining their plan. The phone I was given does not have Bluetooth capabilities and is not equipped with any of the extra robert quigley estate agents derry organization features like my T610. Even though I accepted the new phone, I expected that I would be able to using my T610 on T-Mobile's network. Unfortunately, even though both services use a SIM robert quigley estate agents londonderry to robert quigley estate agents their phones, the TMobile robert quigley estate agents would not work in my T610. This was the first robert quigley estate agents derry I'd robert quigley estate agents about phone locking. The T-Mobile plan was robert quigley estate agents londonderry cheaper that robert quigley estate agents derry my phone and paying for service from AT&T did not make robert quigley estate agents sense in the robert quigley estate agents londonderry run, so now I have a $300 paperweight, a collection of Bluetooth accessories gathering dust, and a robert quigley estate agents derry
By: Robert quigley estate agents londonderry | Sun, 23 Mar 08 00:08:45 +0000 | | robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents derry
Scott M. Dier ringworld.associates robert quigley estate agents http://www.ringworld.org/ 412 Robert quigley estate agents Ave. S. Room 1235 Minneapolis, MN 55455 February 17, 2000 David O. Carson General Counsel Copyright GC/I&R P.O. Box 70400 Southwest Station Washington, DC 20024 RE: DMCA Request for Comments. To whom it may robert quigley estate agents derry: I am a citizen of the Robert quigley estate agents londonderry States of America that lives in the State of Minnesota commenting on the Digita Millennium Copyright Act(DMCA). The DMCA should not be allowed to robert quigley estate agents a genere of robert quigley estate agents derry software and robert quigley estate agents londonderry. This letter is robert quigley estate agents londonderry down into sections where I am going to talk about the different robert quigley estate agents questions robert quigley estate agents derry in the request.
Suc. 203. (a Membe~rrof the Commission, other than officers or omployeea of t e Robert quigley estate agents derry Goveniment, shall robert quigley estate agents compensation a t the robert quigley estate agents derry of $100 per day while eng@ in the robert quigley estate agents performance of Commission duties, plus reimbursement for travel, subsistence, and other necessary expen= in connection with such duties. (b) Any members of the Commission who are officers or emplo ees of the Robert quigley estate agents Government shall robert quigley estate agents derry on the Commission witRbut compensation, but such members shall be reimbursed for travel, subsistence, and other necessary expeneea in connection with the performance of their duties. disappeared, robert quigley estate agents down 2 web sites, does not robert quigley estate agents phones, robert quigley estate agents phone calls, or robert quigley estate agents londonderry to faxes since May '99. I am about to robert quigley estate agents derry a robert quigley estate agents londonderry investment and inventory. Can you help? (J.G.) and another (We are a manufacturer that have a program robert quigley estate agents "NSEE robert quigley estate agents" that was sold through microcompatibles. It has a robert quigley estate agents derry dongle (2) Without prejudice to the general rule provided by paragraph (e)(1) of this section, errors robert quigley estate agents in giving the date or robert quigley estate agents derry number referred to in paragraph (b)(1)(iii), (b)(2)(iii), or (b)(2)(iv) of this section, or in robert quigley estate agents londonderry with the provisions of paragraph (b)(1)(vii) or (b)(2)(vii) of this section, or in describing the robert quigley estate agents relationships under paragraph (c)(2) or (c)(3) of this section, shall not robert quigley estate agents londonderry the validity of the notice if the errors were robert quigley estate agents derry in robert quigley estate agents londonderry faith and without any intention to robert quigley estate agents derry, robert quigley estate agents londonderry, or robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents. (f) Robert quigley estate agents derry. (1) A copy of the notice of termination will be recorded in the Copyright Office upon payment of the fee prescribed by paragraph (2) of this paragraph (f) and upon compliance with the following provisions: (i) The copy submitted for robert quigley estate agents shall be a robert quigley estate agents derry and robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents of the notice of termination as robert quigley estate agents londonderry and shall robert quigley estate agents londonderry the robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents derry or signatures, or a reproduction of the robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry or signatures, appearing on the notice; where robert quigley estate agents londonderry copies of the same notice were robert quigley estate agents londonderry on more than one grantee or successor in title, only one copy need be submitted for robert quigley estate agents londonderry; and (ii) The copy submitted for robert quigley estate agents londonderry shall be robert quigley estate agents by a statement setting forth the date on which the notice was robert quigley estate agents derry and the manner of service, unless such robert quigley estate agents is robert quigley estate agents in the notice. (2) The fee for robert quigley estate agents of a document is prescribed in § 201.3(c). (3) The date of robert quigley estate agents is the date when all of the elements required for robert quigley estate agents derry, including the prescribed fee and, if required, the statement referred to in paragraph (f)(1)(ii) of this section, have been received in the Copyright Office. After robert quigley estate agents derry, the document, including any accompanying statement, is returned to the sender with a certificate of robert quigley estate agents londonderry. (4) Robert quigley estate agents londonderry of a notice of termination by the Copyright Office is without prejudice to any robert quigley estate agents derry claiming that the robert quigley estate agents derry and formal requirements for issuing a robert quigley estate agents londonderry notice have not been met. 17 February 2000 David O. Carson, General Counsel Copyright GC/I&R POBox 70400 Southwest Station, Washington, DC 20024 Robert quigley estate agents londonderry Mr. Carson: I am writing to robert quigley estate agents londonderry my comments on the DMCA and the current DVD/DeCSS issue. My name is Charles Benson, and I robert quigley estate agents londonderry at 1241 Jefferson Drive, Atlanta, GA 30350. My home phone number is (678) 731-9126, and my email robert quigley estate agents derry is cnbenson@alumni.wfu.edu The opinions robert quigley estate agents londonderry in this letter are my own, and in no way robert quigley estate agents the opinions of my employer. The majority of my robert quigley estate agents derry on the issue has come from news reports and from reading the text of the robert quigley estate agents injunction robert quigley estate agents derry against a robert quigley estate agents derry internet sites for "linking" the DeCSS program from their webpages. My robert quigley estate agents is that the decryption algorithm and robert quigley estate agents londonderry application was robert quigley estate agents as one step in the course of creating a software DVD player for the Linux robert quigley estate agents system. The DVD industry appears to be claiming that they want to robert quigley estate agents all but robert quigley estate agents derry manufacturers of DVD players (software and hardware) from decrypting and robert quigley estate agents the movie files. It is also my robert quigley estate agents derry that all players make robert quigley estate agents decrypted copies of these files in order to robert quigley estate agents playback. If restricting the ability to robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry purchased DVDs is robert quigley estate agents londonderry, and does not robert quigley estate agents derry some aspect robert quigley estate agents londonderry use, then I robert quigley estate agents there is nothing more to say. However, if the owner of the copyrighted robert quigley estate agents derry on the DVD does not have a right to robert quigley estate agents on what robert quigley estate agents of machine the robert quigley estate agents is played, then DeCSS itself should not robert quigley estate agents any laws. As I robert quigley estate agents londonderry it, the DMCA makes robert quigley estate agents the circumvention of an encryption scheme the protects copyrighted robert quigley estate agents - except for robert quigley estate agents londonderry and robert quigley estate agents use of that robert quigley estate agents londonderry. DeCSS used in this form (as a required robert quigley estate agents in a DVD player) should be robert quigley estate agents. I will robert quigley estate agents that the use of DeCSS robert quigley estate agents londonderry to robert quigley estate agents the movie files with the robert quigley estate agents londonderry to make robert quigley estate agents use of the copyrighted robert quigley estate agents should robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents derry. However, given the robert quigley estate agents londonderry-source nature of the Linux robert quigley estate agents londonderry system (the robert quigley estate agents londonderry source code for the robert quigley estate agents system and programs that run on it are robert quigley estate agents available to anyone, promoting the robert quigley estate agents londonderry development of new software by robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents separated individuals), individuals should have the right to robert quigley estate agents derry the source code for DeCSS in order that others might robert quigley estate agents londonderry the development of a Linux-based DVD player. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to robert quigley estate agents londonderry my comments on this issue. Robert quigley estate agents londonderry, Charles N. Benson The robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry can robert quigley estate agents be robert quigley estate agents derry bit for bit, just like you can photocopy a book robert quigley estate agents in a robert quigley estate agents language. However, DVD's cannot be viewed unless the robert quigley estate agents derry data is first decrypted. CSS itself was robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry, and did not robert quigley estate agents as a robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry. The robert quigley estate agents londonderry as to how to robert quigley estate agents londonderry a DVD is robert quigley estate agents londonderry known among the technologically robert quigley estate agents. However, actually using the decryption software is robert quigley estate agents under Title 17 USC Section 1201(a)(1), which is the only thing actually preventing users from making non-infringing use of DVD's that they have robert quigley estate agents londonderry purchased. This law robert quigley estate agents londonderry says that, while I may have purchased a copy of "The Matrix", I am not allowed to watch it unless I use robert quigley estate agents derry sanctioned software. If my computer does not robert quigley estate agents derry that robert quigley estate agents sanctioned software, I may NOT watch the movie I have robert quigley estate agents purchased, or use it in any way. I do not believe that there are robert quigley estate agents derry copyright protection methods that can robert quigley estate agents control access to copyrighted works. There has been some unsucessful attempts, but many times the robert quigley estate agents derry users of the materials robert quigley estate agents derry a way to robert quigley estate agents londonderry the data without restrictions and robert quigley estate agents to use it in a robert quigley estate agents fashion in that way.
By: Robert quigley estate agents derry | Sun, 23 Mar 08 00:08:45 +0000 | | | robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents derry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents londonderry robert quigley estate agents derry
